The supervisory institution
Pasal 58
Official copy: salinan p. 26
PP 33/2026 has no article implementing this one. The reading below says what that leaves.
Ayat (5) delegates the detail on the Lembaga itself to a Peraturan Presiden, which had not been issued on 16 September 2026 (CNBC Indonesia).
PP 33/2026 does not create the Lembaga, which UU Pasal 58 ayat (3) and (5) leave to the President and a Peraturan Presiden. The PP defines it at PP Pasal 1 angka 15 only by reference to the statute and gives it supervision and sanctions at PP Pasal 180 and 184. It names no interim holder of those powers, and the Peraturan Presiden had not been issued on 16 September 2026 (CNBC Indonesia).
diverges from the GDPRGDPR Articles 51, 52, 53 and 54
What the GDPR provides. GDPR Article 51 requires each member state to provide for one or more independent public authorities to monitor application of the Regulation. GDPR Article 52 requires each authority to act with complete independence, to remain free from external influence direct or indirect, to neither seek nor take instructions from anybody, and to have its own staff, its own budget and its own premises.
GDPR Article 53 sets the appointment route for the members, which may run through the parliament, the government, the head of state or an independent body, provided the procedure is transparent, and GDPR Article 53(4) limits dismissal to serious misconduct or loss of eligibility. GDPR Article 54(1) requires member state law to fix the establishment of the authority itself, the qualifications, the appointment procedure and a term of no less than four years.
UU Pasal 58 ayat (3) and ayat (4) do two different things and neither would survive under the GDPR untouched. Constitution by presidential instrument is not what GDPR Article 53(1) permits, because that provision lets the head of state appoint the members while GDPR Article 54(1)(a) requires the establishment of the authority itself to be provided by law.
Responsibility to the President is the harder problem, because GDPR Article 52(1) and (2) demand complete independence, and the Court read the equivalent wording in C-518/072 to exclude even the general state scrutiny Germany applied to its Land authorities supervising processing outside the public sector, then in C-614/103 to exclude structural links to the supervised administration.
C-288/124 adds that a fixed term cannot be cut short by restructuring the body, an exposure that cannot even be tested here because UU Pasal 58 fixes no term. The sequencing is the real divergence: GDPR Article 54(1) puts establishment, qualifications, appointment procedure and a term of at least four years into binding law, with dismissal confined by GDPR Article 53(4) to serious misconduct, all of it before the authority starts work.
UU Pasal 58 does no more than say a lembaga carries out the function, leaves its constitution to the President and defers every one of those terms to a Peraturan Presiden not yet made, and each supervision, sanction and dispute provision in PP 33/2026 is addressed to a body whose independence terms are still unwritten.
The petition asks the Court to read into UU Pasal 58 ayat (5) and Pasal 61 a two-year deadline for the Peraturan Presiden that creates the Lembaga and for the regulation on its powers. The fifth hearing, on the petitioners' experts, was held on 11 August 2026.
Decisions of national data protection authorities on the same GDPR provisions, found through The DPO (thedpo.eu), an index of European enforcement decisions, and linked to the authority's own copy. A reference, a date or a fine is shown only where that copy states it. The DPO's summaries are machine-written and none is used here.
The DPO tags 11 national decisions since 25 May 2018, from 6 countries, as citing Article 52; most come from Belgium (5), Greece (2) and Slovenia (1). Listed here are the most recent, one per country, each opened at the authority and found to cite the article.
What GDPRhub's commentary on the same GDPR provisions cites, less what is listed above, each linked to the official copy. It is further reading: the commentary on this page does not rest on it.
Cited in its whole commentary on Article 51. Read it on GDPRhub
Cited in its commentary on Article 52(1). Read it on GDPRhub
The Lembaga. No decision of the Lembaga exists, because it has not been established (CNBC Indonesia, 16 September 2026).