Powered by
The UU PDP wiki
Salinan v5.8 · 28 Sep 2026
BAB IVHAK SUBJEK DATA PRIBADI

Pasal 10 UU PDP

Right to object to automated decisions

awaiting a Peraturan Lembaga

1Legal text

Pasal 10

(1)
Subjek Data Pribadi berhak untuk mengajukan keberatan atas tindakan pengambilan keputusan yang hanya didasarkan pada pemrosesan secara otomatis, termasuk pemrofilan, yang menimbulkan akibat hukum atau berdampak signifikan pada Subjek Data Pribadi. elucidation
(2)
Ketentuan lebih lanjut mengenai pengajuan keberatan atas pemrosesan secara otomatis sebagaimana dimaksud pada ayat (1) diatur dalam Peraturan Pemerintah.

Official copy: salinan p. 6

2Official elucidation

Yang dimaksud dengan "pemrofilan" adalah kegiatan mengidentifikasi seseorang termasuk namun tidak terbatas pada riwayat pekerjaan, kondisi ekonomi, kesehatan, preferensi pribadi, minat, keandalan, perilaku, lokasi, atau pergerakan Subjek Data Pribadi secara elektronik.

3Implementing regulation

Implemented by PP 33/2026 Pasal 93 to 96.

Ayat (2) delegates the detail on objection to automated processing to a government regulation, now PP 33/2026. PP Pasal 96 passes it down again to a Peraturan Lembaga.

PP Pasal 93Subjek Data Pribadi berhak untuk mengajukan keberatan atas…
repeats UU Pasal 10

Subjek Data Pribadi berhak untuk mengajukan keberatan atas tindakan pengambilan keputusan yang hanya didasarkan pada pemrosesan secara otomatis, termasuk pemrofilan, yang menimbulkan akibat hukum atau berdampak signifikan pada Subjek Data Pribadi.

its elucidation

Yang dimaksud dengan "menimbulkan akibat hukum" antara lain keputusan yang memengaruhi:

  1. a.
    status hukum Subjek Data Pribadi, misalnya kewarganegaraan; dan
  2. b.
    penentuan hak atau kewajiban Subjek Data Pribadi menurut hukum, misalnya penolakan visa, penghapusan tunjangan sosial, atau pemutusan kontrak. Yang dimaksud dengan "berdampak signifikan" antara lain keputusan yang berpengaruh besar terhadap kondisi hidup, perilaku, atau pilihan seseorang, seperti penolakan permohonan kredit; penolakan pekerjaan; pembentukan harga berbeda berdasarkan Data Pribadi (differential pricing); dan penargetan iklan yang sangat memengaruhi kelompok rentan.

Read it in the regulationsalinan p. 48

PP Pasal 94Pengendali Data Pribadi harus memiliki mekanisme untuk…
(1)
Pengendali Data Pribadi harus memiliki mekanisme untuk menanggapi pengajuan hak keberatan atas keputusan yang hanya berdasarkan atas pemrosesan secara otomatis.
(2)
Pengendali Data Pribadi harus memberikan Informasi yang memadai mengenai teknologi yang digunakan untuk pengambilan keputusan yang didasarkan pada pemrosesan secara otomatis dan konsekuensi yang akan dialami Subjek Data Pribadi.
(3)
Terhadap pengajuan keberatan sebagaimana dimaksud dalam Pasal 93 yang terverifikasi dan diterima keberatannya, Pengendali Data Pribadi memberikan alternatif pemrosesan Data Pribadi dengan melibatkan campur tangan manusia dan/atau tidak berdasarkan hasil pemrosesan secara otomatis.

Read it in the regulationsalinan p. 48

PP Pasal 95Pengendali Data Pribadi dapat menolak keberatan dalam hal: a.…
(1)
Pengendali Data Pribadi dapat menolak keberatan dalam hal:
  1. a.
    tidak terdapat akibat hukum dan/atau dampak signifikan pada Subjek Data Pribadi; dan
  2. b.
    Pengendali Data Pribadi memiliki akurasi sistem yang sangat baik dan sistem mitigasi untuk menghindari dampak bagi Subjek Data Pribadi.
(2)
Penolakan keberatan oleh Pengendali Data Pribadi tidak menghilangkan hak Subjek Data Pribadi untuk menarik kembali persetujuan pemrosesan Data Pribadi yang telah diberikan sebelumnya.
(3)
Pengendali Data Pribadi harus memberitahukan penolakan sebagaimana dimaksud pada ayat (1) kepada Subjek Data Pribadi.

Read it in the regulationsalinan p. 48

PP Pasal 96Ketentuan lebih lanjut mengenai pemrosesan secara otomatis…Peraturan Lembaga

Ketentuan lebih lanjut mengenai pemrosesan secara otomatis diatur dalam Peraturan Lembaga.

Read it in the regulationsalinan p. 49

4Commentary

4.1How the regulation implements it

PP Pasal 93 to 96 give the objection right a response mechanism at Pasal 94 and enumerated refusal grounds at Pasal 95. This is the statute's own delegation under UU Pasal 10(2) being discharged, but the substantive detail is deferred again at Pasal 96, so the right remains procedurally sketched rather than fully operational.

4.2Where the GDPR stands

diverges from the GDPRGDPR Articles 21 and 22

What the GDPR provides. GDPR Article 22(1) says the data subject shall not be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing, including profiling, which produces legal effects or similarly significantly affects them. Article 22(2) permits such a decision only where it is necessary for entering into or performing a contract, where it is authorised by Union or Member State law that itself lays down suitable safeguards, or where the subject has given explicit consent.

Where the contract or consent gateway is used, Article 22(3) requires the controller to provide at least human intervention, the right to express a point of view, and the right to contest the decision. Article 21 is a separate and wider right, allowing objection to processing grounded in public task or legitimate interests, and absolute objection to direct marketing.

The trigger wording in UU Pasal 10 ayat (1) tracks Article 22(1) closely, down to profiling and the legal-effect-or-significant-impact threshold, so the qualifying clause reads as a lift. What was not lifted is the operative verb. In C-634/214 the Court held that Article 22(1) lays down a prohibition that applies of itself, so the automated decision is unlawful from the outset unless one of the Article 22(2) gateways is open, and the subject need invoke nothing.

UU Pasal 10 instead permits the decision and gives the subject a keberatan to raise afterwards, with the grounds for refusing it fixed by PP Pasal 95, a regulation rather than the statute, and the substance deferred again at PP Pasal 96.

Neither the statute nor the PP carries an equivalent of the Article 22(3) safeguards or the Article 22(4) restriction on sensitive data, so the human-in-the-loop guarantee that does most of the work in EU practice has no Indonesian counterpart. The whole Indonesian right also presupposes the subject knows a decision was automated, which is what Article 15(1)(h) supplies in the EU and what C-203/225 required to be explained in terms the subject can actually use.

5Decisions and guidance

Court of Justice of the EU

  • C-634/21OQ v Land Hessen7 December 2023
  • C-203/22CK v Magistrat der Stadt Wien27 February 2025

National supervisory authorities

Decisions of national data protection authorities on the same GDPR provisions, found through The DPO (thedpo.eu), an index of European enforcement decisions, and linked to the authority's own copy. A reference, a date or a fine is shown only where that copy states it. The DPO's summaries are machine-written and none is used here.

Article 21 GDPRRight to object5 of 245 decisions

The DPO tags 245 national decisions since 25 May 2018, from 24 countries, as citing Article 21; most come from Italy (43), Belgium (28) and Finland (24). Listed here are the most recent, one per country, each opened at the authority and found to cite the article.

  • DecisionRomania, ANSPDCP2026 · fine EUR 2,000
  • 10277005Italy, Garante per la protezione dei dati personaliTIM S.p.A.23 July 2026 · fine EUR 9,516,000
  • 102/2026Belgium, Gegevensbeschermingsautoriteit12 May 2026Under appeal to the Market Court, as the authority's copy said on 27 September 2026.
  • DecisionHungary, NAIH2025
  • Decision of 12 July 2024Estonia, AKI
Article 22 GDPRAutomated individual decision-making, including profiling2 of 5 decisions

The DPO tags 5 national decisions since 25 May 2018, from 4 countries, as citing Article 22(1), 22(2), 22(3) and 22(4); most come from Finland (2), Austria (1) and Italy (1). Listed here are the most recent, one per country, each opened at the authority and found to cite the article.

  • 10074601Italy, Garante per la protezione dei dati personaliFoodinho s.r.l.13 November 2024 · fine EUR 5,000,000
  • DecisionGermany, BlnBDI2023 · fine EUR 300,000

Cited on GDPRhub

What GDPRhub's commentary on the same GDPR provisions cites, less what is listed above, each linked to the official copy. It is further reading: the commentary on this page does not rest on it.

Article 21 GDPRRight to object1 judgment · 1 EDPB document

Cited in its whole commentary on Article 21. Read it on GDPRhub

Article 22 GDPRAutomated individual decision-making, including profiling1 EDPB document

Cited in its commentary on Article 22(1), 22(2), 22(3) and 22(4). Read it on GDPRhub

The Lembaga. No decision of the Lembaga exists, because it has not been established (CNBC Indonesia, 16 September 2026).

6Cross-references

Referred to by

7Sources

  1. 1UU 27/2022, salinan, p. 6.
  2. 2Penjelasan UU 27/2022, salinan, p. 40.
  3. 3PP 33/2026, salinan: Pasal 93 to 96 at pp. 48 to 49.
  4. 4Case C-634/21 OQ v Land Hessen, 7 December 2023, ECLI:EU:C:2023:957. EUR-Lex.↑
  5. 5Case C-203/22 CK v Magistrat der Stadt Wien, 27 February 2025, ECLI:EU:C:2025:117. EUR-Lex.↑
  6. 6GDPRhub (noyb), commentary on Article 21 GDPR, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as captured on 26 September 2026. GDPRhub.
  7. 7GDPRhub (noyb), commentary on Article 22 GDPR, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as captured on 26 September 2026. GDPRhub.