Powered by
The UU PDP wiki
Salinan v5.8 · 28 Sep 2026
BAB VIKEWAJIBAN PENGENDALI DATA PRIBADI DAN PROSESOR DATA PRIBADI DALAM PEMROSESAN DATA PRIBADI

Pasal 38 UU PDP

Protection from unlawful processing

sanctioned by Pasal 57 ayat (1)

1Legal text

Pasal 38

Pengendali Data Pribadi wajib melindungi Data Pribadi dari pemrosesan yang tidak sah.

Official copy: salinan p. 16

2Implementing regulation

Implemented by PP 33/2026 Pasal 129.

PP Pasal 129Pengendali Data Pribadi wajib melindungi Data Pribadi dari…sanction list
repeats UU Pasal 38

Pengendali Data Pribadi wajib melindungi Data Pribadi dari pemrosesan Data Pribadi yang tidak sah.

Read it in the regulationsalinan p. 62

3Commentary

3.1How the regulation implements it

PP Pasal 129 requires protection against unlawful processing and is sanction-backed. It operates as the general duty behind the specific security measures at Pasal 123 and 130.

3.2Where the GDPR stands

aligned with the GDPRGDPR Articles 5, 6, 24 and 32

What the GDPR provides. The GDPR splits unlawful processing in two. GDPR Article 6(1) makes processing without one of the six legal bases unlawful in itself, which is a lawfulness question under GDPR Article 5(1)(a). GDPR Article 5(1)(f) is the other half and is a security duty, requiring that data be processed in a manner ensuring protection against unauthorised or unlawful processing and against accidental loss, destruction or damage, by appropriate technical and organisational measures.

GDPR Article 5(2) makes the controller responsible for both and able to demonstrate it, and GDPR Article 24(1) requires measures appropriate to risk that are reviewed and updated.

UU Pasal 38 does not say whose unlawful processing is being guarded against, and that silence carries the article. Read as a security duty it lands on GDPR Article 5(1)(f), protection of the data from unlawful processing by others. Read as a lawfulness duty it lands on GDPR Article 5(1)(a) with Article 6(1), processing without a basis.

The tracker places it with PP Pasal 129 beside the security provisions, which resolves it the first way, and the resolution matters because the two produce different defences. A security failure is judged by whether the measures were appropriate.

A lawfulness failure is judged by whether a basis applied, which is a narrower argument, though not a closed one, since GDPR Article 6(1)(f) turns on a balancing of interests and Article 6(4) on a compatibility test.

The GDPR keeps the two apart on purpose, which is why Article 5(1)(f) has Article 32 to say how the duty is discharged while Article 6 has no equivalent article of measures, only the conditions at Articles 6(2) to (4), 7, 8 and 9.

C-340/213 shows the appropriateness route running, with the burden on the controller to prove its measures were adequate and an intrusion not proving by itself that they were not, and C-807/214 shows how far responsibility for other people's unlawful acts reaches, to any person acting in the course of the controller's business and on the controller's behalf.

4Decisions and guidance

Court of Justice of the EU

  • C-340/21VB v Natsionalna agentsia za prihodite14 December 2023
  • C-807/21Deutsche Wohnen SE v Staatsanwaltschaft Berlin5 December 2023

National supervisory authorities

Decisions of national data protection authorities on the same GDPR provisions, found through The DPO (thedpo.eu), an index of European enforcement decisions, and linked to the authority's own copy. A reference, a date or a fine is shown only where that copy states it. The DPO's summaries are machine-written and none is used here.

Article 5 GDPRPrinciples relating to processing of personal data5 of 2,056 decisions

The DPO tags 2,056 national decisions since 25 May 2018, from 29 countries, as citing Article 5(1) and 5(2); most come from Italy (350), Spain (193) and Latvia (171). Listed here are the most recent, one per country, each opened at the authority and found to cite the article.

Article 6 GDPRLawfulness of processing5 of 1,187 decisions

The DPO tags 1,187 national decisions since 25 May 2018, from 28 countries, as citing Article 6(1), 6(2) and 6(4); most come from Belgium (133), Italy (131) and Hungary (117). Listed here are the most recent, one per country, each opened at the authority and found to cite the article.

Article 24 GDPRResponsibility of the controller5 of 189 decisions

The DPO tags 189 national decisions since 25 May 2018, from 16 countries, as citing Article 24(1); most come from Latvia (70), Poland (32) and Belgium (29). Listed here are the most recent, one per country, each opened at the authority and found to cite the article.

Article 32 GDPRSecurity of processing5 of 931 decisions

The DPO tags 931 national decisions since 25 May 2018, from 29 countries, as citing Article 32; most come from Denmark (155), Romania (152) and Latvia (70). Listed here are the most recent, one per country, each opened at the authority and found to cite the article.

  • 10297203Italy, Garante per la protezione dei dati personali3 September 2026
  • DecisionRomania, ANSPDCP2026 · fine EUR 5,000
  • DKN.5131.5.2025Poland, UODO25 May 2026
  • DecisionIreland, Data Protection Commission2026 · fine EUR 300,000
  • DecisionGermany, BlnBDIBerliner Verkehrsbetriebe (BVG)2026

Cited on GDPRhub

What GDPRhub's commentary on the same GDPR provisions cites, less what is listed above, each linked to the official copy. It is further reading: the commentary on this page does not rest on it.

Article 5 GDPRPrinciples relating to processing of personal data4 judgments

Cited in its commentary on Article 5(1)(a), 5(1)(f) and 5(2). Read it on GDPRhub

Article 6 GDPRLawfulness of processing16 judgments · 8 EDPB documents

Cited in its commentary on Article 6(1), 6(2) and 6(4). Read it on GDPRhub

Article 24 GDPRResponsibility of the controller1 judgment

Cited in its commentary on Article 24(1). Read it on GDPRhub

Article 32 GDPRSecurity of processing2 judgments · 2 EDPB documents

Cited in its whole commentary on Article 32. Read it on GDPRhub

The Lembaga. No decision of the Lembaga exists, because it has not been established (CNBC Indonesia, 16 September 2026).

5Cross-references

Referred to by

6Sources

  1. 1UU 27/2022, salinan, p. 16.
  2. 2PP 33/2026, salinan: Pasal 129 at p. 62.
  3. 3Case C-340/21 VB v Natsionalna agentsia za prihodite, 14 December 2023, ECLI:EU:C:2023:986. EUR-Lex.↑
  4. 4Case C-807/21 Deutsche Wohnen SE v Staatsanwaltschaft Berlin, 5 December 2023, ECLI:EU:C:2023:950. EUR-Lex.↑
  5. 5EDPB, Guidelines 4/2019 on Article 25 Data Protection by Design and by Default. EDPB.
  6. 6GDPRhub (noyb), commentary on Article 5 GDPR, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as captured on 26 September 2026. GDPRhub.
  7. 7GDPRhub (noyb), commentary on Article 6 GDPR, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as captured on 26 September 2026. GDPRhub.
  8. 8GDPRhub (noyb), commentary on Article 24 GDPR, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as captured on 26 September 2026. GDPRhub.
  9. 9GDPRhub (noyb), commentary on Article 32 GDPR, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as captured on 26 September 2026. GDPRhub.